In re SVB Financial Group - Listen to the U.S. Court of Appeals argument re FDIC setoff rights, held on 1/26/26, and link to the ruling in the episode notes hero artwork

In re SVB Financial Group - Listen to the U.S. Court of Appeals argument re FDIC setoff rights, held on 1/26/26, and link to the ruling in the episode notes

International Bankruptcy, Restructuring, True Crime and Appeals - Court Audio Recording Podcast ยท
00:00:00
00:00:00
Notes
Transcript
Download

Transcript

00:00:00
We'll start right away, with, INRAY SBB Financial Group, case number 25567. And I understand, mister Carr, are you are you here?
00:00:14
Yes, your honor.
00:00:16
And... Okay. Please proceed.
00:00:20
Thank you, your honors, and may it please the court. For three overriding reasons, a straightforward construction of the bankruptcy code and related principles compels the conclusion that the FDIC has forfeited the claims underlying its asserted right of set off. First, as the FDIC now concedes, the claims underlying its asserted right of set off plainly fall within the code's expansive definition of claim in section one zero one five. The bankruptcy court rested its decision on the opposite premise, but the FDIC does not even attempt to defend that ruling here. Second, as claims under the bankruptcy code, the FDIC's claims are subject to the same allowance rules as other claims.
00:01:07
The right to set off is simply a means of effectuating mutual debts, but there can be no set off without an an allowed claim to begin with. And third, the FDIC's attempt to avoid that conclusion based on section five five three of the code fails. Section five five three simply preserves the right of set off under state laws. As the text of section five five three a one itself makes clear, claims subject subject to set off must still be allowed, And that's exactly what the third circuit held in the Continental Airlines case. As that court put it, and I'm quoting here, the right to set off must be exercised by the creditor in a timely fashion and in accordance with other provisions of the bankruptcy code.
00:01:52
Regarding... Quick question. Now, the FDIC here was not intending to seek an affirmative recovery in the bankruptcy proceeding. Correct?
00:02:06
I don't think that's correct, your honor. I mean, to to begin with, the the defensive
00:02:11
The FDIC was seeking an affirmative recovery in the bankruptcy proceeding?
00:02:15
It had a claim, your honor, and its claim
00:02:18
My my my question is, was it seeking a recovery in the bankruptcy proceeding? An affirmative recovery in the bankruptcy proceeding.
00:02:27
So it didn't file a proof of claim, your honor, and that's why we're in
00:02:29
this sense.
00:02:30
Answering my question, counselor.
00:02:32
Well, I am. I'm saying no. It's... Well, I'm saying yes. It it was in this sense, your honor.
00:02:37
It it it had a claim under the bankruptcy code. The bankruptcy code in no way distinguishes between offensive claims and defensive claims. In fact, the the definition
00:02:47
Why why would a party submit a proof of claim in a bankruptcy proceeding if it was not going to seek a recovery in the bankruptcy proceeding?
00:02:58
So, your honor, the reason why congress established that scheme was to first identify all claims that pertain to the the debtor and its estate, and secondly, to resolve all those claims, provide notice of all those claims in one proceeding. Now this is particularly important here because at issue is the $2,000,000,000 in deposits that the FDIC's FDIC's seized from, SVP. Those are all part of the bankruptcy estate. That's a critical part of the estate. And whether or not SVP ends up writing a check to the FDIC or the FDIC uses those funds to offset something, that's directly impacting the bankruptcy risk.
00:03:40
And so, therefore, it was
00:03:41
The FDIC had already paid out $15,700,000,000 to the, uninsured depositors of SVP. Right?
00:03:52
I believe it did, your honor, but it had no right to keep SVP's deposits. It put it in a different situation, and that's a key part of the bankruptcy arrest. And that's why the third circuit held correctly that under the bankruptcy code, all claims have to go through the same claims allowance process.
00:04:08
Part of the bankruptcy res is the claim to the money. Right? It's the... The money is actually titled to the bank, not to the debtor.
00:04:18
It is part of the bankruptcy rest rest, your honor. Absolutely. The claim to the funds. Right? And the claim to the funds.
00:04:24
Absolutely.
00:04:24
And the claim to the funds is subject to defenses. Right? You'd never make this argument about defenses. So if you and I have a contract and I never paid you and you think you have a claim for breach of contract, you have a claim. That's an asset.
00:04:38
A claim against me for breach of contract, but it wouldn't extinguish my right to say that actually you failed to perform and I didn't need to pay you, if I don't file that defense as a proof of claim. Right?
00:04:52
That's right, your honor. I mean, I...
00:04:54
But defense works that way. And in fact, you know, I could... You could imagine that being either a defense or an affirmative claim. Maybe I thought that your performance was so bad that you actually owe me damages. If I wanna recover something from you, I would have to assert it affirmatively as a claim.
00:05:10
But if it's a defense to liability, that would never be extinguished. So if you bring an action against me for breach of contract to recover the money you say that I owe you, if my defense is I don't actually owe you the money because, you breached first, that wouldn't be extinguished. And so if the state law allows set off as a defense, why shouldn't it work the same way?
00:05:35
Well, I think... I mean, one thing is, your honor, I mean, this court in the Lehman Brothers case characterized set off as a permissive counterclaim, and that's really the way it works. I mean, if you look at the claims here, they're just like traditional claims. The FDIC is asserting them against, the the the bank here. And, you know, that's a claim under the bankruptcy code.
00:05:55
And...
00:05:55
But why should why should we understand it that way? Like I'm saying, so if I want to get more from you than what's already in my possession, then certainly I do have to bring it as a counterclaim. But if I'm just trying to defend against your claim to get money from me on the ground that I don't actually owe you that money and get to keep it in my possession, why wouldn't we understand that as a defense? Like, isn't this the kind of thing that could be made as a claim or as a defense?
00:06:21
So I think you'd go to the definition of claim in one zero one five, your honor, of the code. And that makes clear that a claim is any right to payment. It's extremely expansive as the Supreme Court said in the Johnson case or enforceable obligation.
00:06:35
But so... But why wouldn't I understand that to mean a right to payment, meaning that I want money to change hands? So if you're suing me for breach of contract, I don't actually want a payment for you. I'm just saying you're not entitled to a payment from me. Right?
00:06:51
That kind of a thing could be raised as a defense without saying that I have a right to payment from...
00:06:56
Well, I think that the the Supreme Court in the Johnson case, your honor, said right to payment or enforceable obligation, and that's what the FDIC is asserting against SVP here. And, again, this goes to $2,000,000,000, which are, you know, a key part of the bankruptcy risk. And so the question is, and the third circuit recognized this in the Continental Airlines cases, is that completely outside of the claims allowance process or not? And the FDIC here...
00:07:21
I'm sorry.
00:07:23
Where where
00:07:23
where does the right to payment arise in this case? I thought it was California law.
00:07:30
Well, the the FDIC is asserting a right of set off under California law, your honor. It's asserting a right to be paid based on alleged breaches of fiduciary duty and the like, and it's asserting entitlement to 2 billions... $2,000,000,000 in funds that it sees. And and just to be clear, if if the trust wins this case, the money at issue, the $2,000,000,000, will go directly to creditors. If the FDIC wins this case, it will go to the FDIC.
00:07:59
And that's not the way the bankruptcy process is intended.
00:08:01
Can I go back? Can I go back? I'm sorry. Go ahead, Jasmine.
00:08:05
I was gonna say, sometimes that is how the bankruptcy code works. Right? So there is... So we... You know, usually, there's a very small window for avoiding a preferential transfer because sometimes the bankruptcy code says, oh, if you were just repaying a bona fide debt, we're gonna leave well enough alone unless it's within the ninety days of, bankruptcy.
00:08:25
Right? And so why wouldn't we understand that the bankruptcy code is making the same judgment as to a set off if it's a bona fide, debt that the creditor is retained... The money that creditor is retaining. It doesn't make sense to say we're gonna send it back to the debtor just to achieve a kind of ideal equal distribution among creditors as long as we don't think that there's something going on?
00:08:50
So I think the code answers that question, your honor. I mean, again, if you go to five five three, which is the provision that the FDIC primarily relies upon. I mean, it it says that the right to set off, is not affected by the code. That just means that state law is in displace. But then it goes on to say that there's no right of set off unless you have an allowed claim.
00:09:09
Well, it doesn't say unless you have a allowed claim. It says that there is a right of set off unless the claim is disallowed, and that's consistent with
00:09:16
the
00:09:16
idea that if you're trying to affirmatively recover money from the estate as a set off, you might you might file a proof of claim. It doesn't necessarily mean that if you're asserting it defensively, it would be allowed or disallowed. Right?
00:09:32
Well, I...
00:09:32
I mean, sometimes the code says something like it must be allowed. But like in this case, in five fifty three, it says, we preserve the right of set off unless, it's specifically been disallowed.
00:09:44
Well, the code makes clear first it identifies what our claims within the the process of the code, and then secondly, what claims are allowed. The code at five zero two b two... B nine makes clear that, you know, an untimely claim is not allowed. Rule 3,002 of the bankruptcy rules makes clear that you must file a proof of claim for it to be allowed. And so this notion that you could have...
00:10:07
That anyone who has a claim within the meaning of the bankruptcy code can simply opt not to participate in that process. I mean, that's antithetical to the way that the bankruptcy process works.
00:10:17
But why isn't it? I mean, I guess I don't know if I got an answer to that question about raising a defense to liability. So if an asset of the estate is a claim for breach of contract and the creditor against whom the estate, believes it has... That claim has a defense to the liability, it's true that it would extinguish the value of the claim if that defense were to succeed, but you would never say that that that it would have to file a proof of claim to preserve its defense to liability. Right?
00:10:48
So I think one thing about that, your honor, is that would be a recruitment, not set off. Recruitment is a defense in the same, Yeah.
00:10:55
I understand. So actually... So in my hypothetical, it's about a breach of contract claim, and the defense is that, actually, you've reached as part of the same transaction. So I get that. But why should it be a different result if we had two separate transactions and it works the exact same way?
00:11:10
Because state law allows me, to raise as a, defense to your claim that we had a prior transaction in which you owe me money, and so I get to retain the money that's in my possession.
00:11:25
Well, I I think for traditional defenses, your honor, like a statute limitations or something like that. But if we're talking about what is in essence a counterclaim, which is the way that this court itself has described the set off, I think it's different. And to be clear here, the FDIC has acknowledged that its its claims arise from a different transaction or occurrence than the the bank's claim against... Trust claim against the FDIC itself. These are completely different claims.
00:11:52
And you start with this question of whether what the FDIC is asserting is a claim within the meaning of the bankruptcy code.
00:11:57
And and so may I go back may I go back to your answer to my question about California law, which is, one source of, the definition of claim at least in the context of this particular case. Right? You would agree with that?
00:12:13
I agree that the right to set off comes under California law. The question of what the claim
00:12:17
is is As as as... Well, as I understand it, the defendant can only assert under California law, but maybe I'm not no expert in this area of California law, can only assert the set off defensively to defeat a plaintiff's claim. So it's not... California does not regard this as a claim. It regards this as a avenue to defeat a claim.
00:12:38
What... What's your answer to that?
00:12:39
My answer to that is section one zero one five of the bankruptcy code, which governs what is a claim for these purposes. You know, how the set off right works is a matter of state law, but whether or not what the FDIC is asserting is a claim under the bankruptcy code.
00:12:54
But you but you refer... But but this... You referred to the language, which, you know, I agree with that. And you referred, in the first instance to a right to payment and... As the, really the central definition for our purposes of a claim.
00:13:13
And California law seems not to define a defensive set off as a right to payment? It defines it as something else.
00:13:25
So what the Supreme Court said in the Johnson case interpreting this language, your honor, is it's extremely broad and that it refers to any enforceable obligation, and that would apply here. It it doesn't matter whether it's disputed or not, liquidated or not, contingent or not. You know, all of those things would apply here. And the FDIC itself concedes that what it is asserting is a claim within the meaning of the bankruptcy code. And the bankruptcy court got that...
00:13:46
Well, your understanding of claim would
00:13:52
of claim would apply also to, recruitment claim. Right? Or to, defense to liability like I was describing?
00:14:01
It would it would apply to recruitment, certainly, your honor. I mean, there... There's separate rules.
00:14:06
Recruitment is a claim and you're acknowledging that it doesn't have to be raised in a proof of claim, then it means that there are some things that meet your definition of claim that don't need to be subject to a proof of claim.
00:14:17
Well, I I don't think I've acknowledged that, your honor. I mean, I I would ask first, is this a claim? And then you have to, you know, if it is, then you have to file a timely proof of claim or it's not lying.
00:14:27
Even for even for a recruitment defense, you're saying it needs to be... A timely proof of claim needs to be filed?
00:14:32
I think it would. I mean, you know, again, look at the other circuits that have addressed this issue. I don't think they've disputed it that the the, you know, claim underlying the right of set off. Or the set off is just a mechanism. It's the claim underlying it.
00:14:45
Is a claim within the meaning of the bankruptcy code? I mean, certainly the third circuit recognized that in the Continental Airlines case. And if you go through the bankruptcy code, again, five five three, the set off provision refers to the claim being dis allowed.
00:14:58
As I just described it that you have a claim against me for breach of contract because I never paid you. But I think we all understood that since you never performed, I didn't have to pay you. How would I even know that I have a claim against you unless you come after me for the payment?
00:15:13
So, I mean, here, first, your honor, it's undisputed that the FDIC knew that it had claims and simply decided not to assert them. That's it, SPA one ninety one to 92. I mean, if you didn't know about it, then you'd have a defense of excusable neglect, which would excuse the failure to file a timely notice, proof of claim. And then second, just to be clear on the hypothetical, you know, set offs are different. They arise out of a different transaction or occurrence.
00:15:40
So it's not like a traditional defense whether you call it, recruitment or
00:15:43
something else. But it's... In my hypothetical, there's one contract between us, and you think I breached and I think you breached. But I I just... What I guess I don't get is why it would be very different if there were two contracts between us.
00:15:57
And I think that your breach, allows me to set off, your claim for my breach on the other contract.
00:16:05
So I think in your hypothetical, your honor
00:16:07
Especially, state law allows me to do that.
00:16:09
Right. What you would be asserting as a counterclaim, I would say you breached the contract and you would counterclaim and say, no. You... I've reached the contract. That would be a counterclaim.
00:16:19
That would be a claim within the meaning of, the bankruptcy code. And it would be just like the claim here. I mean, this court again in Lehman Brothers case described set offs as permissive counterclaims. They're they're traditional claims in every sense, except at the end of the day, you have the opportunity to set off a mutual debt. And this case would be no different if if if the FDIC was asking the SVP bank, or trust to write a check to it versus canceling off this 2 billions of dollars, which is, you know, at the heart of the bankruptcy race and which should be distributed to creditors through the bankruptcy process.
00:16:55
And really... Can I can I ask?
00:16:56
So if that's the way it works, then what is five fifty three doing, you think?
00:17:01
Yeah. So first of all, it's doing something really important. It's making clear that the bankruptcy code doesn't override the state laws governing right to set off. And this is something going back, you know, centuries in equity. And so it's really important.
00:17:16
Second, it also, interplays with section five 42 of the bankruptcy code, which is the turnover action.
00:17:24
The right You actually are saying it kind of overrides the state law. Right? Because if California allows you to raise the set off defensively, you're saying no. But the bankruptcy code treats that as a claim, and therefore, it's subject to a proof of claim and will be extinguished unless it's recognized in the plan.
00:17:39
Well, I think that's an important point, your honor. I agree in that respect because that's what the code requires. And five five three itself makes that clear by saying, like, look. This this does not affect the right to set off, which comes under state law. The Supreme Court made that clear in the Strumpf case.
00:17:54
So then there only is a right of set off if it's recognized in the plan. Right?
00:17:58
The... But in order to exercise that right to set off, it doesn't work if the claim is not allowed. I mean, that's what five five three a one itself makes clear. And five zero six a one makes that clear too when it says that a a claim that is allowed, is a secured claim for purposes of set off, an allowed claim of a creditor that is, subject to set off under five five three. And, again, that that makes clear that
00:18:23
And is that is that clear that it's affirmative or defensive set off?
00:18:28
It says an allowed claim, your honor. I mean, the affirmative or defensive concept is, not found in the code. It's actually contradicted by the language of one zero one five that we've referred to. It's something that's invented by the courts, and it doesn't really make any sense because any set off right or assertion of a set off is by its nature defensive.
00:18:48
So we've we've let you, go well past your time. We'll hear from the FDIC. I know you've reserved some time for rebuttal, and I thank you. So we'll hear from the FDIC.
00:18:59
Miss Good morning. May it please... Thank you. Good morning. May it please the court.
00:19:03
Michelle Agnibeni on behalf of the FDIC as receiver for Silicon Valley Bank and Silicon Valley Bridge Bank NA. I think that mister Gar made clear that we agree with SVB Financial on one point. We think the plain language of the code controls this matter. But where we differ is that we think that, the specific provision directed at set off, section five fifty three, should be the, the touchstone here. Section five fifty three a says this title does not affect any right of a creditor to offset a mutual pre petition debt, except except as provided in that section.
00:19:41
Like pretty much every court to address it, we think section five fifty three means what it says. If a creditor satisfies the requirement of the section, its right to assert set off is unaffected by any other provision, including those that could be construed as requiring a proof of claim or discharge. Applying the plaintext of section five fifty three a doesn't result in any extreme disruption of the bankruptcy process, and that's because that off is typically defensive and requires no payment from the estate. They're just looking to reduce or extinguish
00:20:12
What's
00:20:12
the the function of that first provision that says you don't get the right of set off if the claim was not allowed?
00:20:21
I think... Well, actually, I I... Just to clarify, that provision says that a claim, must not have been disallowed. And disallowed is used in a particular way in the code. It means that something has been disallowed after presentation, objection, and disallowance on the merits.
00:20:39
When a proof of claim is not filed, it can't be disallowed. There's no revision of that claim. And when would
00:20:46
you file a proof of claim for us at OAuth?
00:20:49
I think that there are situations in which, a a creditor is seeking something more than just a dollar for dollar set off. They might be looking for additional relief on top of the set off, and then they would need to file a proof of claim.
00:21:03
We don't think that some actual money from the from the estate.
00:21:08
Exactly. Exactly. They're looking for no benefit. Are you
00:21:12
So are you saying that when it's raised defensively, it's not a claim for payment?
00:21:17
Well, I think that it can be. The the claim underlying the set off is a claim under one zero one five. We would concede that. But the assertion of set off in itself does not act as a claim because there's no right to payment being asserted, though there is an underlying way
00:21:35
that that you're that you're not even defending the view of the bankruptcy court that a defensive set off is not actually a claim. Is that accurate?
00:21:43
I think that the bankruptcy court didn't quite say that. There is some language to that effect, but, really, what the bankruptcy court seems to be driving at, if you read the entire opinion, is that there's a difference between a defensive claim for set off and an affirmative claim for payment. And so... And those are actual words used in the bankruptcy court's decision. So I think that it's not quite that the bankruptcy court thought that the definition of claim had no application, but that the defensive assertion of set off does not involve a right to payment.
00:22:16
They're not seeking a right to payment. So it
00:22:19
And isn't right to payment the definition of claim? So if you're saying you're not seeking a right to payment, doesn't that mean it's not a claim?
00:22:26
That could be one way of looking at it, but I think that we would concede that the concede that the claim... That there is a claim underlying the setup of that.
00:22:32
Your... That must be your primary argument, that it's not a claim.
00:22:38
I I I think that we would concede that there is a claim underlying the setup defense. It's just we have chosen not to assert a right to payment.
00:22:46
Meaning that you think that you could have asserted affirmatively a claim for payment from the estate, but your preference is to leave well enough alone. And as long as they don't come after you to recover the money they think they're owed, you're not asserting any claim for payment from the estate.
00:23:00
Exactly. Exactly.
00:23:01
That's that's why, the word defensive might, apply, but you're also moving away from that.
00:23:09
No. No. We we we would acknowledge that we have asserted it as an affirmative defense. It is a... We have asserted set up as an affirmative defense in the Northern District Of California litigation, but we do not think that we needed to file a proof of claim to preserve that affirmative defense.
00:23:27
So if you're filing it as an affirmative defense and not as a counterclaim, then is in your position it's a defense and not a claim?
00:23:35
Yes. It it... I I... Yeah. It is a it is a defense.
00:23:39
We... That's the only thing that we've asserted.
00:23:41
So it's a defensive set off that you describe as an affirmative defense. I'm just... You're... These words No.
00:23:48
I'm sorry. Yes. To me? Yes. Yes.
00:23:51
Yes. It is, I I think under California law, it would be described as... It would be categorized as an affirmative defense, but it's not seeking affirmative relief. That's the distinction. We're not seeking affirmative relief.
00:24:02
That under the relevant law, the assets here are titled to the bank and not to the debtor. So if in fact, the estate had titled to the funds, you would need to assert a proof of claim because you'd be seeking payment from the from the estate. Right?
00:24:20
Yeah. I think that's right. I think that it is important that, the estate does not own the funds. It owns a cause of action to try to recover the funds. There is a distinction there.
00:24:31
This is money that was in the FDIC's hands, at the time the bank failed, and so that is, you know, our basis for keeping it in case we can set it off because we thought that we would have claims against the, SBB Financial.
00:24:48
So when I was saying, to mister Gar the analogy to a defense to liability or to a recoupment, defense, he pointed out that this kind of a set off is about two different transactions. Even defensively, to a claim for payment based on one transaction, money that you're owed under a different transaction, why shouldn't we just understand that as a separate claim that needs to be preserved in bankruptcy?
00:25:15
Well, I think that section five fifty three a covers set offs, and set offs by definition are two different transactions. Otherwise, it would be recoupment. And so the... You know, Congress didn't seem to care that they were two different transactions in preserving them. So I don't think that it should really matter, you know, that that we're set...
00:25:33
Asserting set off versus recruitment because that's not what Congress chose to protect.
00:25:40
Okay. So your your argument about why five fifty three allows for the extinguishment of a right of set off if the claim is disallowed, you give meaning to that provision by saying that you have discretion to assert affirmative... To assert the set off as a claim, but you don't have to. Right?
00:25:59
Yes. And that's...
00:26:00
So why so why would that why would that be? So that means that sometimes you might need to assert it and it might be disallowed, and so then the code might extinguish a right of set off, but sometimes you could just preserve it defensively. I mean, why shouldn't there just be a uniform rule for how we treat set offs? The the the code doesn't seem to distinguish between types of set off.
00:26:23
No. I think that the code does not distinguish between types of set off. I think, though, that to the extent a creditor is seeking something on top of set off and additional affirmative relief, we don't think section five fifty three necessarily would extend to file proof of claim to seek that. I think that tradition... The the courts that have addressed this and have distinguished between defenses and counterclaims, usually, the counterclaim did involve some additional affirmative relief that the creditor was seeking, and so that's why there...
00:27:00
That distinction developed. But I suppose if it were a purely, you know, dollar for dollar set off asserted as a counterclaim, there wouldn't really be a principled basis for distinguishing that
00:27:11
and using it as a defense. When you say
00:27:14
when you
00:27:14
say set off again, words matter. When you say set off asserted as a counterclaim, so that would be a counterclaim saying whatever whatever we owe them, they owe us as an affirmative claim.
00:27:28
Yeah. That that is one way to do it. California allows for both ways of asserting set off. It clearly does allow assertion as a
00:27:39
Could you have asserted this defensive claim slash set off as an affirmative claim in the bankruptcy case?
00:27:49
I suppose we could have, but we didn't. And
00:27:52
But if you had and then it was disallowed, then you wouldn't be able to, seek it, as, under five fifty three.
00:28:03
Yes. That's true. And the reason why we didn't, though, there are good reasons outside of the bankruptcy code why we did not file a claim in the bankruptcy. FIRIA, our own statute provides for resolution of failed banks, and it provides for jurisdiction in only two courts, that can hear claims against the receiver. And knowing that
00:28:27
wanted to wait for the debtor to come after you affirmatively
00:28:32
because you choose
00:28:33
the venue. Right?
00:28:36
Give... Given the the statute
00:28:38
specifies the venue. It's not that you chose it, but the statute Yes.
00:28:41
The statute specifies the venue.
00:28:43
If you had filed a proof of claim to preserve your claim, and it were allowed, you would have gotten extra benefits. Right?
00:28:52
I don't know that... I I don't know that we would have gotten extra benefits. It's... I think it I think it could have been treated as a secured claim, and maybe we would have gotten paid. But it's hard to know what's with that hypothetical.
00:29:07
There's a lot of steps that would have to happen.
00:29:09
Let let me follow-up then with that... With with following question. What what what is the disadvantage to the FDIC to filing, if any, to filing a proof of claim in this context?
00:29:24
I think that then we would be... We would have to submit to the bankruptcy court's jurisdiction, which Congress didn't really want us to do, and that's why it restricted jurisdiction over claims against the receivership to two court... Two district courts. And we would have to go through the bankruptcy process. And, given that we had title to the funds and we had, set off written into the deposit agreement, given the huge hit to the diff that, was caused by the mismanagement of the bank, It seemed irresponsible to the bank's own creditors to pay over that money just for the chance of getting
00:30:03
it back. If I were if I were
00:30:05
an ordinary if I were if I were an ordinary creditor, so not the... Not in the FDIC's unique, position, What is the what is the disadvantage?
00:30:18
I think this... The same thing is that they would have to go through the bankruptcy process. And Congress said that, you know, many courts have said that creditors shouldn't have have to go through that process. Their set off rights are preserved even if they don't file a proof of claim in the bankruptcy.
00:30:34
Well, but for the oddity that there's this fight... This FIRIA specifies a different venue for them to recover from the FDIC. Probably the way it would happen with any other creditor is that there'd be an affirmative action or an adversary proceeding within the bankruptcy court. Right? And then the creditor would raise a defensive set off in that...
00:30:53
To that proceeding.
00:30:56
It could happen that way. The courts that have had to address this issue about, about set offs, you know, when... In the absence of a proof of claim, obviously, that did not happen. There were just separate actions where debts were trying to be recovered and the setup was asserted. And, and so those those situations, the courts found that, you know, no proof of claim was necessary because of section five fifty three's plain language.
00:31:22
And even post discharge, three courts of appeals held that the set off could be asserted post discharge.
00:31:27
What about what about what about the third circuit in in Continental?
00:31:32
The third circuit really limited its its holding to the facts of that case. In fact, it distinguished the two other courts of appeals decisions that it discussed in the ninth circuit de Laurentiis and the tenth circuit Davidovich based on the differences in facts. They didn't really take issue with their statutory analysis so much. And the facts... And and it's it's notable that it distinguished it on the facts because, in De Laurentiis, a proof of claim was filed.
00:31:59
But in Davidovich, no proof of claim was filed. But the reason why the third circuit found that it was distinguishable was because there was some notice of the set off defense. And so that's pretty much the situation that we're faced with here even more so. We... You know, the FDIC did object to the plan before confirmation, so no discharge actually occurred with respect to the s...
00:32:23
FDIC set off defenses.
00:32:25
I think it also relies on this earlier case, Norton, that says that the funds withheld by the creditor subject to set off were property of the estate, and it acknowledges that that principle doesn't survive the Supreme Court's decision in Strumpf. But then it says, oh, but the state has a right to the funds subject to the government's defenses. And so that's why you can't assert the set off. But, like, obviously, the defenses include the defensive set off. Right?
00:32:51
I'm not sure it makes a lot of sense the way they try to reconcile it with the earlier... With STRUNF.
00:32:58
Right. I think that, Strumpf, you you can't really construe it the way that SBB Financial has argued because they say that Strumpf, it... Oh, it preserves set off defenses that, were... Are creatures of state law subject to the claims allowance process. I don't know where that subject to the claims allowance process comes from in Strumpf.
00:33:19
In fact, in Strumpf But you agree that it's...
00:33:21
That is subject to the claims allowance process to some extent. Right? Because you're saying it's possible to file a proof of claim to assert a right of set off, and it's possible for that claim to be disallowed. So there is a degree to which, it's subject to the claims allowance process. You're just saying that there's this discretion that a creditor with the right of set off has to either file a proof of claim or not.
00:33:48
Yes. I think that's right.
00:33:51
Some... You said something about submitting to the jurisdiction of the bankruptcy court or having it decided outside. Is it... Would it be the case that sometimes there'd be a right to a jury trial on a liability outside the bankruptcy process, but maybe if you file a proof of claim, you wouldn't? Could that be a difference sometimes between the two approaches?
00:34:13
Perhaps. I haven't looked into that issue specifically.
00:34:19
K. Thank you very much.
00:34:21
Okay. Thank you.
00:34:23
Mister Gar, you've got three minutes of rebuttal.
00:34:26
Thank you, your honor. The FDIC says it should be resolved by the text, but it ignores the text. And look at five five three a one again, which makes clear as the claims that are disallowed or not subject to set off. The only reasonable interpretation of that is that set off claims are subject to the same claims allowance process and other claims as
00:34:44
Doesn't it... It makes sense that that provision applies only if the creditor submits a claim.
00:34:51
If if you No. In respect
00:34:53
Hold on. If you submit a claim and it's disallowed, then you then the decision has been decided against you, but doesn't mean you have to submit a claim.
00:35:02
Right. In no other context would a creditor say I have the right to decide whether or not to participate in the bankruptcy. Rule 3,002 specifically says that a creditor must file a proof of claim. And that that principle would run rough shot over the entire bankruptcy code because the whole point is to identify claims, require people to file timely proof of claims, and then resolve those claims in one proceeding. Once proof of claim is filed, you can seek judge Manashi to refer that to an article three court.
00:35:32
And, you know, they could have filed a proof of claim. And if they wanted to assert that in an article three court, Southern District Of New York, they could have tried that. They didn't. They wanted out of the bankruptcy process because they wanted special treatment, apart from all the other creditors. With respect to......
00:35:47
Special treatment. I mean, they're saying, like, if you're coming after the FDIC, to get money from their corpus, you have... There's a statute that says where you have to proceed, and they're saying, well, we're gonna we're gonna rest on that, and so we're gonna raise it as a defense in that proceeding as opposed to submitting ourselves to the bankruptcy court. I mean, that makes this kind of idiosyncratic. Normally, there wouldn't be such a statute for a creditor, but but why is that nefarious?
00:36:15
Why isn't that just the way we have the two statutory schemes interacting?
00:36:20
Well, they're just wrong about that with respect, your honor. The FIRIA applies to claims against the FDIC. This court recognized that in the first millennium case. It doesn't apply to claims brought by the FDIC. The FDIC itself has sued us in the Eastern District Of California.
00:36:35
The FDIC is not bringing a claim for set off. It's just saying our defense to your claim against us for breach of contract is that we have a right of set off that allows us to retain the funds. Right?
00:36:46
It has. It's asserting a claim as this court has described set off, sir, permissive counterclaims in every respect as the FDIC acknowledged in the confirmation hearing of this case. And this is the best
00:36:56
mean that you're saying they're permissive counterclaims in every respect? I mean, like, literally in the proceeding in the Northern District Of California, it's being raised as a defense and not a counterclaim. Right?
00:37:06
That is true, your honor. That's the way they weigh it.
00:37:09
When you're describing it as a counterclaim, you're saying we should just decide that based on the nature of things, it really is a counterclaim even though that's not the way it's treated in the actual legal proceeding.
00:37:20
Well, I mean, that... That's the way this court... Your court itself has characterized it, your honor, and that's right. That's the way the law has always looked at set off claims. I mean, the set off is just a mechanism for canceling out mutual debts.
00:37:33
But still, how states treat the set off differently. Right? There's some states that don't allow an unliquidated set off claim. Right? Like here, you know, for a breach of fiduciary duty.
00:37:43
It would require, you know, a fixed amount or something. There are different rules about when and under what circumstances it can be asserted. And if five fifty three says we're preserving the right of set off that exists independent of bankruptcy, why shouldn't it be the case that depending on how the right of set off is treated under the law that applies that confers on the creditor the right of set off, that's the way it should be understood, whether it's a defense, a counterclaim, or, could be either.
00:38:13
Because, your honor, five fifty three itself makes clear that a claim, given rise to a sort of set off does not work if the claim is disallowed. And so then you're left with this question of whether you can just opt out of the bankruptcy scheme altogether. In no other, situation as to no other creditor would you think that a creditor could just say, like, oh, no. I went out of bankruptcy. I'm not gonna file a proof of claim.
00:38:38
The the code... It makes no sense to construe the code as a claim that that is not allowed is not a claim that is...
00:38:44
But isn't that again kind of a feature of the idiosyncratic character of this case? So as I said, in most cases, there isn't gonna be a statute that provides for, venue in a different district, from where the bankruptcy is occurring. But... So if if this were not the FDIC but a normal creditor, instead of suing in the Northern District Of California, you'd bring an adversary proceeding in the bankruptcy court to recover. Right?
00:39:08
And it would come before the bankruptcy court.
00:39:11
Well, it could it could be in any court, your honor, because set off by definition
00:39:14
Oh, but that's what you would
00:39:15
be doing.
00:39:15
Right? Because you'd be the one recovering. I mean, here, the venue provision requires you to go to California. But if there were not that statute, you could bring an adversary proceeding in the bankruptcy court, couldn't you?
00:39:29
I think we, we... FIRREA required us to sue the FDIC on a court plan.
00:39:37
But I'm saying if if FIRREA didn't exist and you wanted to recover money from a creditor for the estate, you could bring an adversary proceeding in the bankruptcy court. Yes. Yes.
00:39:48
No. That's right. But the question for the court
00:39:50
is idea about opting out of the bankruptcy process, and not coming before the bankruptcy court, it's only a feature of the idiosyncrasy that FIRIA has this venue provision that doesn't allow you to bring the adversary proceeding in the bankruptcy court, but requires you go... To go to the district where the, you know, where the the bank was.
00:40:13
No. No. It doesn't. That's not right, your honor, with respect because they could have filed a proof of claim. They would have had their claims, the FDIC's claims, adjudicated in the bankruptcy court or if they had sought referral to the SDNY.
00:40:27
And then the result of that proceeding would have applied in the California proceeding. They could have then asserted the set off. And if they No.
00:40:34
Right. I'm saying... I I understand that. But even if the bankruptcy court and the FDIC are right about the way we should understand the nature of a defensive set off, I'm saying in normal circumstances, it would still come before the bankruptcy court because the debtor could bring an adversary proceeding in the bankruptcy court. The only reason it's coming...
00:40:52
It's happening in a separate court is because of FIRIA.
00:40:56
I mean, as to the f... As to our claims against the, FDIC, that's why we're in Northern District Of California, but that doesn't excuse the FDIC from following the claims allowance process as to its claims, which arise out of a separate transaction or occurrence and are what the Northern District Of California described as independent actions. They're completely separate. And that's why FIREAA is just really a red herring here. It doesn't do any work for the FDIC.
00:41:25
The question is under the bankruptcy code, is the FDIC asserting, a claim underlying its right to set off. If it is, then the code makes clear in five five three a one and five zero six, a one two and other provisions that that claim has to be funneled through the claims allowance process. And that's exactly what the Continental Airlines case holds. I mean, the FDIC has tried to distinguish that on factual grounds, but the holding of the Continental Airlines was that the... Under the bankruptcy code, a claim underlying asserted right to set off is subject to the same timeliness rules and other rules of the bankruptcy code as any other claim.
00:42:02
And if it had been different, your honor, then the FDIs... Then the party in that case could have proceeded with its claim. The reason why that claim failed in Continental Airlines is because the court held correctly that claims underlying a right to set off are subject to the same rules as to other claims. The FDIC decided unilaterally to exempt itself from that process. No other creditor could have done that, and we're simply asking this court to hold the FDIC to the same rules that apply to every other creditor.
00:42:31
Thank you very much.
00:42:33
Thank you.
00:42:34
We'll we'll reserve decision.